Sunday, January 2, 2011

Internal Emergency

Internal Emergency is back in the news courtesy a book released during the Congress party’s recent plenary, which gives its account of the events of 1975. The news reports reveal that late Sanjay Gandhi, younger son of Indira Gandhi has been largely blamed for what went wrong. These must be references to shifting of slum-dwellers to resettlement colonies on the outskirts, forced sterilisation & bull-dozing in areas near Turkman Gate to shift Muslims to Inderlok. There may be some truth in it since Sanjay Gandhi was not only the active face of Congress party at that time. Most ardent supporters of emergency, including V.C.Shukla, who implemented press censorship & Jagmohan who executed Turkman Gate plan appeared to be directly reporting to him. Curiously many members of Sanjay Gandhi’s coterie, including his wife Maneka and son, Varun, subsequently found place in BJP (see Pankaj Vohra’s piece in today’s HT). One wonders whether blaming Sanjay for what has been described by Advani as a ‘Nazi rule’ is, in part, family politics since Congress is today headed by the senior sister-in-law while the junior and her son are in the Opposition camp.
Needless to recollect that Internal Emergency was hastily declared in the wake of Indira Gandhi’s disqualification by Jagmohan Lal Sinha of Allahabad High Court on a petition filed by Raj Narain alleging misuse of govt. machinery during the polls. I recollect a cartoon by Abu showing the then President Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed handing over the signed declaration from a bath tub and asking them wait if there were more papers to sign. Beginning June 12, 1975, Opposition leaders were taken into preventive custody and many innocent people, including college teachers of DU, ended up in jail. Therefore it is incorrect to put the entire blame on Sanjay Gandhi for a step meant to save his mother from being unseated. The way many people, who occupied prime places later, crumbled like a pack of cards during the police raj was shocking as well as revealing. Barring Indian Express, which had the temerity to leave the edit space empty to protest censorship and invited retaliatory raids as a consequence, the media ‘kneeled when it was asked to bend’. Seminar was the only magazine, which continued to debate the issues freely. The reason, explained by a friend in I & B Ministry, perhaps was the academic nature of its content and small circulation, which posed little danger to those in power. Most people saw Emergency only in terms of punctuality in offices and running of trains and most critics of establishment turned sycophants for the sake of convenience and out of fear. Several diehard activists of political parties, taken into custody under DIR apologised to secure release from prison while those under the more strident MISA spent the entire 18 months behind bars.
Those who were born later and did not see the dictatorial face of Indian officialdom will be amused by the way Emergency affected people at the micro level. Shyamlal College, which was experiencing trouble in the Seventies, got a new Principal, G.C.Ahuja, courtesy DU’s then VC. The Governing Body of the Trust was sent packing and both the Vice-principals were out of sight-one under detention and the other underground. The temporary staff of the Evening College, a part time D.P.E & two office clerks, was removed arbitrarily. There was a curious reversal with new faces, either with an anti-Trust image or keen to acquire one to escape the ordeals of Emergency, thronging the office of the officiating Vice-principal. Colleagues spied on one another and official complaints went to local police alleging opposition to infamous 20-point/ 5-point programs of Indira Gandhi & Sanjay Gandhi. A teacher went all the way to Jammu to help police apprehend the Vice-principal who had fled in time. A senior teacher was summoned from his Kidwai Nagar residence at midnight to explain the ‘RSS connections’ alleged in the college complaint. What was heartening was the way more than half of Evening College refused to be cowed down and even issued a legal notice to the management when wages were denied to the staff to protect the Principal. Signed by ‘I.J.Bhatia & 18 others’, it created an identity for the rebels. Teachers, who were soft-spoken or remained quiet revealed exemplary fortitude when the more militant ones sometimes wavered, felt insecure and needed to be convinced. A few even indulged in double-dealing with the authorities. Emergency became a good example of how people could indulge in vindictiveness or settle personal scores: it brought out the worst in us. Fortunately, a Stay Order prevented the college from initiating any disciplinary proceedings against permanent employees throughout the Emergency. Indira Gandhi lost the election & the new Principal fled the college the same evening with lots of files, never to return.
The wheel had come full circle!

Wednesday, December 22, 2010

To Vote or Not to Vote!


Come election time & staff rooms of Delhi’s colleges are swarmed with familiar faces of teachers’ activists laden with cards introducing the candidates, many with identical names, and their ballot numbers, to aid the memory of the forgetful voters. The established groups owing allegiance to different political outfits also issue pamphlets, which state their positions on immediate as well as long term issues. These positions often become so predictable and repetitive over time that most teachers just accept the ‘declarations of intent’ as a matter of courtesy and leave them on side tables to serve as coasters for the endless cups of tea. Reading, in any case, is a taxing, tedious and tiresome activity & the curious ones find it easier to just shoot a question and let the sermonizing begin. As battles lines get blurred and the polling draws nearer, subtle attacks and even innuendos fill up spaces between the lines. Your vote may be sought on any plausible ground- from departmental appointments/irregularities, caste/gender-oppression/empowerment, neo-colonial policies & medieval mindsets- nothing is taboo. There are honourable mentions of ‘struggles’, which need to be carried on and the ‘academic reforms’, which are often destined to be still-born. Parties or groups other than yours dole out lacs while you have to manage on a shoe-string budget created by ‘help from well-meaning & like-minded friends’. Many ‘independent’ candidates sound look content with ‘any preference’ from strangers since it is the floating vote that can act as a spoiler. The more confident ones have the box near their names on the huge poster checked to indicate to which candidate your college has been allotted to but cross-voting does happen. Like the proverbial middle-class in national/civic elections, there are the apathetic voters too who just don’t show up despite reminders, phone calls & offers of transport/refreshments to tempt them. Things can dramatically change when a wage rise/cut is in the offing.

Where do the university elections differ from the rest? A group called ‘Forum for Democratic Struggle’ blamed its ideological ally for all the possible ills plaguing the system, expressed constraint that it cannot vote for a candidate not its own and in fact appealed ‘to teachers to cross out the form for the Executive Council elections’. After all, the right to vote does include the right not to cast one’s vote. The democratic struggle may have just taken a U-turn!

Sunday, October 31, 2010

Jaya Row on Bhagavad Gita


To say that Bhagavad Gita is a profound scripture would be an understatement. Every time you read it, its verses yield newer meanings. The interesting thing is that one can find what one is looking for in it. For the superficial reader, it is an exciting narrative of an epic war; for the informed one, a philosophy of life. When I learnt about Jaya Row’s series of lectures devoted exclusively to Chapter IX, I rushed to Kamani auditorium on the appointed day filled to the brim with curiosity. How is she going to talk about it for four days when it takes me quarter of an hour to dispose it off?

The organizers, Vedanta Vision, very thoughtfully summed up the chapter under the title ‘The Royal Secret’ in a brochure and followed it up with all the 34 verses in Sanskrit, which I am no good at but sounded extremely melodious when played during the lectures. Fortunately there was an English translation for the uneducated, which right at the beginning promised to declare the ‘most profound secret-knowledge along with wisdom’ but only to one ‘who does not criticise’. Was I destined to be the ignorant one?

Jaya Row is an eloquent speaker who unfolded the ‘royal knowledge’ as one ‘directly realisable, righteous, very easy to practise’. She preferred the original ‘sraddha’ to its poor equivalent in English ‘faith’ since the former has elements of complete devotion and surrender lacking in the latter. Knowledge comes only to one willing to listen with empathy (shravan), think over it deeply (manan) and is willing to imbibe or become what is taught. For those devoid of faith, there is the fearful prospect of return to this mortal world.

Jaya Row changes her demeanour constantly- from a smiling, reassuring one when getting a right response from someone in the audience to a stern school-master like the next moment. ‘Are you understanding or just sitting in an air-conditioned hall?’ Quoting from earlier Chapters of Bhagavad Gita and Upanisads, she explains how the life cycle of an individual is too miniscule in a Kalpa to be much consequence. Therefore, she exhorts, do not worry about nation or the world but save your own self from the destructive influence of an illusory (mayavi) world.

The aim has to be karma or action, which is neither selfish nor even selfless since both lead to desires albeit of a different kind. Discarding ‘vain hopes, futile actions, hollow knowledge’ and ‘delusive nature’, one has to worship the Lord with ‘single-mindedness’. Jaya Row explains how Om formed with sounds a, u and m raises one’s consciousness from the mundane to the divine when chanted with steadfast devotion.

Calling for change in attitude, Jaya Row employs humour to drive home the need to drop negativity in thought and behaviour. ‘You are not upset when a neighbour’s dog barks because you understand it is the prakriti or nature of that creature. ‘Why get upset when your wife barks at you’, she asks tongue in cheek. ‘I am the same in all beings, nobody is hateful or dear to me’, she quotes Verse 29 to emphasize how the Lord and all the worshippers are in one another.

Jaya Row dismisses Verse 32, which clubs those ‘of sinful birth, women, vaisyas and sudras’ as the most misunderstood one claiming women in all scriptures have been portrayed as goddesses. Not very convincing since the tone and tenor of the verse clearly implies that despite being lowly, ‘they also attain the supreme Goal’. It might have been better to accept that perceptions change over time and it is the underlying message in the last verse, which is important. “Fix your mind in Me, be My devotee, sacrifice to Me, prostrate to Me…..you shall come to me.’ Amen!

Wednesday, October 27, 2010

Letters to Editor (Misc.)

Rai’s views about English (Outlook, Aug 23, 2010) were at best puerile; Das was far more cogent in outlining the new role English has been playing in an India spurred by technology and growth. This is surely not the language taught in fossilised universities and colleges with their archaic curriculum and conceited faculties. The ‘Globish Inglish’ contemptuously referred to by Rai, which evolved in business centres and management institutes as a skill, has fast emerged as the language of communication across different states and even nations. This is borne out by the US administration’s recent move to raise the visa fee manifold for Indian technocrats and software professionals wanting to go there. There is no need to dream of India in English but many of us can surely realise our dreams through it.

J.M. Manchanda, New Delhi

Tuesday, October 5, 2010

Of Teachers and Registers!

Who hasn’t been tormented by the arduous attendance business at school! Teachers still begin their day by taking the infamous roll call followed by countless ‘yessirs’ or ‘present mams’ reverberating in the classrooms. No one ever protested even when asked to stand outside the class for being a latecomer and monitors walking by with a tell-all smile. Today when members of the same fraternity, albeit at a higher level resist recording their own attendance and become the subject of a deriding edit in a major national daily (HT, Oct. 4), it is time to ponder over the issue.

I remember attending a UGC-sponsored conference on Post-war literature in Chandigarh where a clerk used to walk in to make us record our attendance on a piece of paper. This entitled about a dozen of us to our meagre dearness allowance and measly meals. Though we signed the slip without a murmur, the British professor found the exercise in the middle of the session quite irksome and repeatedly asked if it was really necessary.

No one ever imagined that teachers of a premier university would ever play truant or do less than what was expected of them. In fact to guard against over-burdening them, it was one profession where the maximum, not the minimum, work-load was prescribed. ‘No teachers will be given more than eighteen periods a week’, the rule mentioned. In a similar strain, teachers were not expected to record their presence but were assumed to be present unless on leave. In the same spirit, most teachers remained accessible and went out of the way to turn institutions into centres of excellence. Luckily many still do.

With expansion, attitudes also gradually changed. The standards began to be diluted. I still remember some of my junior colleagues protesting why we need to come every day or apply for leave when one or the other member was spotted only rarely in college and got away with it. The principal did try once in a while to reason with the offenders but were silenced by angry denials. The disease spread over time. One of the jokes doing rounds in staff rooms now is that one should no longer ask about the ‘Off day’ but the ‘working day’.

This is not to justify the contents of the edit. Much of it was false and frivolous. The average salary of a college teacher is less than half of what was quoted. Considering most of them are unable to enter the profession these days till they are in their late twenties or early thirties takes much of sheen off that figure. Most still continue to work for long, past their marriage and parenthood, teaching on ad-hoc or guest basis. In any case, it is not enough to ensure the presence of a teacher, essential though it is, but to create an atmosphere, which encourages him to deliver his best. This is only possible with fair selection followed by periodic assessment and rewards.

Accountability is a good argument. You can’t just go on saying ‘No’ to everything. No internal assessment marks, no admissions, no time tables, no new academic calendar, no exams in November, no semester system at UG level, no biometric system, no revision of courses, no centralised evaluation. In short, no work but all pay! But accountability is a two-way sword. Accountability is surely not limited to teachers signing an attendance register.

Let all of us on the campus, and let us begin at the top, ask ourselves whether we have acted fairly, diligently and delivered our best on the job. Perhaps the answer will not be very flattering!

Saturday, October 2, 2010

CWG-Festival of Food in CP


Cocking a snook at the sceptics, crowds thronged Bhai Khadak Singh Marg where a Festival of Foods began on the eve of opening of CWG. People filled up space in front of States’ emporia where creativity unleashed itself in several forms.Bamboo was used generously to build benches, arches and sculptors with lights adding colour to the event. Folk dances on an open stage drew repeated applause from the onlookers while the rest literally queued up to click pictures of a unique wedding procession depicted in roped sculptors with a bride sitting demurely in a palanquin and her groom astride an elephant. Food and crafts from States as far as Manipur and Rajasthan were on offer with seats thrown in imaginatively. There was an air of festivity all around with scoops of ice-cream and Chandni Chowk’s paranthas adding to what was available in the Food Court. The only regret! There weren’t many tourists who have apparently stayed back in the wake of intense negative coverage in our media. To make amends, the media may now onwards focus on the brighter side but the damage cannot be undone.

Meanwhile Delhites have decided to hop on & enjoy themselves to the hilt.


As one drove back on the outer circle, there was another surprise in store. The shack-like shops housing Kake da hotel etc. near Super Bazaar had been redone to become replicas of the famed inner circle.

Thursday, July 8, 2010

Of Slaps & Schools



Schools are back in the news. This morning the papers are full of an eleven year old jumping down from the second floor of a school after he was slapped for being late. The institution is ironically named after Mother Teresa, recognized the world over as an icon of love and care. The news revived memories of Govt. Senior Secondary School, Lalpani, Simla, which I visited along with

my wife early this month. While sitting in the office of the Principal, Mr. R.C.Rangra, a teenaged Akhtar Ali was brought in who was accused of habitually jumping over the rear wall of the school and playing truant. The mild-mannered principal hardened his voice and demeanour and asked him why he did not choose the front gate. The handsome and slightly awed Ali thought for a moment and then merely said, ‘Short-cut’. It wasn’t much of an offence in my eyes since I too had done it several times while at school. Ali was luckier since he was dismissed only with a warning. I used to receive heavy caning when caught. I wondered if he had benefitted from our presence and asked the principal whether corporal punishment was given at his school. He denied it but he and my wife, who also teaches at a school, agreed that sometimes it becomes necessary to discipline the ‘tough’ boys.

I should have started on a different note. The school established more than a century ago, 1848, to be exact, and a decade older than the more popularly known British Cotton School, breathes history from every nook and corner. There was a Board listing the principals and their tenures. When I found one Bhagwan Singh, sandwiched between five or odd Englishmen, I asked Mr. Rangra if it meant Indians were good enough in those days to get the top slot. He agreed and revealed that it must have been a primary school in those days. Mr. Zia-ul-Haq, the former army chief and head of Pakistan was a student of what is now widely known as Govt. School, Simla. In fact the record of his birth was called for and sent to Pakistan following his death.

The School with 1400 students and a Staff of 70 offers all streams in two shifts. My wife was inquisitive about the infrastructure. There are ten class rooms, two offices and five labs. There was a computer in Mr. Rangra’s room so we deduced IT must be one of the subjects. Most students came from the middle or lower-middle class with about 25% managing to build good careers later. I scanned several medals and medallions lining the wall behind him. He confirmed most were won in sports & cultural events. He took us round the corridor with curious eyes peeping out of a class room. There was a locked almirah with the words ‘Old English Books’ painted at the top. I fought the instinct to ask if it could be opened and we could look at the spines of the hidden treasure. The Class room next to it with its polished wooden ceilings and creaking weathered floors had a colonial look.


Principal Rangra’s own career graph was interesting. He studied Electrical Engineering and worked for Navy before he discovered his love for English Literature did his Master’s from H.P.University and became a lecturer in 2001. He took over as Principal of Lalpani School five years later and has been managing its affairs well. We thanked him for his hospitality and took his leave only when the incessant rain outside took a short break. No short-cuts for us!